If you’ve lived in Winnipeg for more than a season, you already know that our climate is not for the faint of heart — and neither is our housing. From sizzling +30°C summer days to -40°C winter nights, along with the occasional spring blizzard, your home’s roof is your first defence against the elements.
For decades, roof replacement has been all about conventional asphalt shingles. Asphalt shingles have improved in quality over the years, with fibreglass replacing the felt mats of the past, thus extending their life expectancy from a controversial 15-20 years to a pleasant 30-35 years for most types of houses. Because the material is easy to work with, and familiar to just about every roofing contractor in North America, labour costs for the installation of fibreglass shingles are lowest of all available roofing materials. Not too long ago, if you wanted a roofing material with greater longevity than conventional shingles, you’d have to shell out for a truly premium material – cedar shakes, or in Winnipeg synthetic versions of shakes, slate, or tiles. These materials were priced far out of reach of the average homeowner, increasing the proliferation of the more affordable asphalt shingles.
Today, metal roofing is giving homeowners a real alternative to fibreglass shingles. At Above All Roofing & Exteriors, we install both metal roofing and shingle roofing, and we’ve seen first-hand how each performs in Winnipeg’s unique conditions. This guide is designed to help you weigh the pros and cons of metal roofing vs shingled roofings so you can make the right choice for your home.
We’ll explore:
- Climate-specific performance
- Material differences
- Lifespan and durability
- Cost and long-term value
- Maintenance and environmental impact
- Which option suits different homeowner needs
By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of whether a metal roof, asphalt shingles, or even a composite material is the right fit for you.
Climate Considerations for Winnipeg Roofs
Winnipeg’s climate challenges every type of roofing material. So it’s important your roof is properly installed, and is able to withstand these elements.
Can Your Roof Withstand Winnipeg Elements?
- Freeze-thaw cycles: Temperature swings cause materials to expand and contract, which can loosen fasteners and open gaps over time.
- Snow loads: Heavy snow accumulation puts extra weight on your roof deck and roof system.
- High winds: Prairie gusts can lift compromised shingles or metal roofing panels if they aren’t properly installed.
Why Proper Installation Is Important
This is why proper installation, insulation, and ventilation all work hand-in-hand to protect your investment. It’s important to inspect the roof deck underneath before starting work, ensure proper air circulation to prevent condensation, and use proven sealing methods for both asphalt shingle roofs and standing seam metal roofs.
Can Your Roof Avoid Ice Damming?
Ice damming — where melting snow refreezes at the eaves — is another common winter problem. The good news? Both properly installed metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofing can resist ice damage when paired with the right underlay and ventilation.
What Are the Main Differences Between Metal and Shingle Roofing?
When it comes to replacing or upgrading your roof, the decision between metal roofing and shingle roofing is one of the most important choices you’ll make. On the surface, it might seem like the difference is simply about appearance, but in reality, the two options vary in almost every way — from the materials used and how they’re installed, to how they perform in extreme weather and how long they’ll last before needing replacement. Understanding these differences is crucial, especially for Winnipeg homeowners, where roofing materials are tested by heavy snow loads, high winds, and drastic temperature swings. Choosing the right option can influence not only your home’s curb appeal but also its energy efficiency, maintenance needs, environmental footprint, and overall value. Let’s take a closer look at how metal roofing materials and asphalt shingles compare in both form and function, so you can make a confident, informed choice for your next roofing project.
Material Composition
- Metal Roofing: Typically made from steel roofing or aluminium. At Above All Roofing & Exteriors, we use Snaplock hidden fastener profiles for a watertight, low-maintenance finish. This includes standing seam metal roofing — a premium option known for durability and sleek looks.
- Shingle Roofing: Most asphalt shingles are made from a fibreglass mat coated in asphalt, with granules for UV protection. We offer trusted brands like Cambridge and Dynasty, as well as designer asphalt shingles such as Armourshake and Estate, which replicate the look of wood shakes or slate.
Aesthetic Options
- Metal Roofs: Sleek, modern lines with a more limited colour range, but the visual impact is strong. Perfect for contemporary homes or rustic cabins looking for a bold statement.
- Asphalt Shingles: Wide variety of colours and profiles. Architectural asphalt shingles can mimic traditional wood shingles or even concrete tiles, giving homeowners more flexibility in matching their home’s style.
Durability and Lifespan
The two materials have very different performance timelines, and that difference often becomes the deciding factor for many homeowners. Metal roofs are widely regarded as a long-term investment — when properly installed, because they can last 40 years or more, while some standing seam metal roofs reaching the half-century mark without major issues. Their resistance to high winds, heavy snow, and even hail means they’re less likely to require emergency repairs, and their minimal maintenance needs make them appealing for homeowners who want a “fit and forget” solution. In contrast, asphalt shingle roofs generally have a shorter service life, ranging from 25 years for standard architectural asphalt shingles to around 50 years for premium designer options. While shingles are easier and more affordable to repair if a section becomes damaged, they can be more susceptible to curling, cracking, or granule loss over time — especially in a climate like Winnipeg’s, where freeze-thaw cycles can accelerate wear. Ultimately, understanding the lifespan and durability of each material helps you weigh the higher metal roof cost against the frequency of shingle installation or replacement over the years.
Metal Roofs
- Lifespan: 40+ years, with many lasting 50 years or more.
- Weather resistance: Excellent against high winds, snow, and hail.
- Maintenance: Low — typically limited to periodic inspections.
- Sustainability: Fully recyclable at the end of life.
Asphalt Shingle Roofs
- Lifespan: 25–50 years, depending on the grade (architectural vs. designer shingles).
- Repairability: Easier to repair small sections without disturbing the rest of the roof.
- Vulnerability: More prone to damage from extreme weather if not installed by a skilled roofing contractor.
Cost Comparison and Long-Term Value
While metal roof cost per square foot is typically higher than asphalt shingle roofing, the lifespan and reduced maintenance can make it more economical over decades.
| Feature | Metal Roofing | Asphalt Shingles |
| Upfront Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Lifespan | 40–50+ years | 25–50 years |
| Repairs | Less frequent | More frequent |
| Long-term Value | High | Moderately High |
Above All Pro Tip
Even on shingle roofs, we often use metal valleys in leak-prone areas like steep slopes to extend lifespan.
Another Roofing Material Option: EuroShield
If you want something in between an asphalt shingle roof and metal roofs, composite shingles like Euroshield combine durability, curb appeal, and eco-friendliness — and they’re made from recycled materials! For more composite roofing options, see our EuroShield Shake & Slate roofing options here.
Maintenance and Repairs
No matter which roofing material you choose, some level of upkeep is unavoidable, but the type and frequency of maintenance can vary greatly between metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofs. Metal options tend to require fewer repairs over their lifetime, while shingles are easier to fix in small sections but may need attention more often — especially after Winnipeg’s severe weather events.
Pro & Cons
- Metal Roofs: Minimal maintenance, but if a panel is damaged, matching colour and finish can be tricky.
- Asphalt Roofs: More frequent upkeep, especially after severe storms. However, replacing a few shingles is faster and less disruptive than replacing metal roofing panels.
Winnipeg homeowners often choose traditional asphalt shingles for their easier maintenance during harsh seasons, especially if they prefer doing small repairs themselves.
Environmental Impact
Your roof’s effect on the planet is about more than just how it’s made — it’s also about what happens when it reaches the end of its life. Metal roofing materials are fully recyclable, reducing waste, while asphalt shingles can also be repurposed in Winnipeg, often finding a second life in road construction projects.
- Metal Roofing Systems: Made from recyclable materials and fully recyclable at end of life. Reduced waste compared to traditional roofing materials.
- Asphalt Shingles: While not as green, they are recyclable in Winnipeg, often repurposed in road construction. Above All Roofingparticipates actively in this asphalt roofing recycling process.
Which Option Is Right for You?
Here’s a quick homeowner profile breakdown:
- Budget-conscious → Architectural shingles and asphalt roofing shingles
- Longevity-focused → Metal roofing products like standing seam metal
- Luxury curb appeal → Designer shingles or composite roofing
No matter your choice, Above All’s in-house trained installers ensure your roof is not just beautiful but built to handle Winnipeg’s extreme weather.
Why Choose Above All for Your Roofing Project?
You’re not just hiring a roofing contractor — you’re partnering with a team that has:
- 21+ years of local experience
- A 7-year workmanship warranty
- Standard upgrades like drip edges and metal valleys at no extra charge
- Experience with every roof pitch and style in Winnipeg — from Wolseley character homes to modern North Kildonan bungalows
- We also understand additional integrations like solar roofing and can help you choose materials compatible with solar panels for future energy upgrades.
Conclusion: Let’s Talk About Your Roof
Whether you’re leaning towards properly installed metal roofs, architectural asphalt shingles, or a premium designer product, the right choice depends on your home’s style, your budget, and how long you plan to stay in your house.
At Above All Roofing & Exteriors, we take the time to explain the pros and cons of shingles vs. metal roofing, look at your existing roof, and recommend the best roofing materials for you and your home.
Book your free estimate today and find out which roofing solution will protect your home — and look great doing it — for decades to come!